France's four largest telecom operators spent Saturday on standby for an instruction that never came. A letter dated 22 October, published two days later by the investigative outlet Blast, shows Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu asking Orange, SFR, Free and Bouygues Telecom to be ready to cut access to Snapchat, TikTok and Instagram — and, once the letter went out, X — within hours, by filtering domain names.
The day before he signed it, his interior minister told the Senate no such control was being proposed.
What the letter asked for
Addressed to the heads of Orange, Bouygues Telecom, Iliad (Free) and Altice France (SFR), it says the prime minister wants "the option of temporarily suspending access to these services in the event of a repeat of urban violence". Operators were to "anticipate from today" the technical work so that, "if I give the instruction", they could suspend the services "without delay" for "a few hours" — possibly "the weekend of 24 and 25 October, depending on the operational context". The letter asks for "the confidentiality necessary for preparing this measure", which is "exploratory in nature at this stage".
Matignon's reason: platforms played a "decisive role" in spreading unlawful calls and coordinating violence — organising looting, trading targets, moving groups.
The Senate, one day earlier
Asked in the Senate on 21 October what he would do about platforms, interior minister Laurent Nuñez said: "For technical and legal reasons, control of social networks has not been proposed at this stage." He added: "The reflection continues, but we are extremely prudent." He flagged suspending networks during looting as "another lead", under the "very strict" conditions the Council of State set in 2025. The next day the capability was being ordered anyway.
Why the operators pushed back
A 70-minute call on 23 October followed, with the operators' legal directors. According to the minutes Blast obtained, they were unconvinced. The government wanted a block limited to mobiles and to specific areas; they said they could not deliver that at short notice, and that a VPN or another messaging app would defeat it. Their lawyers cited the national scope, the ease of circumvention and the proportionality of cutting three platforms for up to twelve hours.
They also disputed the form: operators wanted a published, reasoned act — Orange a formal arrêté — not a private instruction.
The test any block would have to pass
The legal basis was a Council of State ruling of 1 April 2025 that had annulled the previous attempt: the order cutting TikTok in New Caledonia during the 2024 riots. Exceptional circumstances can justify a temporary interruption, the court held, but only if it is indispensable, no softer alternative is immediately available, and it lasts no longer than finding one takes. New Caledonia failed on duration: that block ran until the government lifted it on 29 May 2024.
Brussels is asking the same question
On 23 October, 30 MEPs wrote to executive vice-president Henna Virkkunen asking the Commission to use its Digital Services Act investigative powers on how the footage and looting calls spread, and to say whether violence of this kind counts as a "crisis" under Article 36, which lets the Commission require large platforms to assess their contribution and act. They noted the DSA allows access to be restricted as a last resort only on a judicial authority's order, a step the French route skipped.
What is still unconfirmed
- One outlet holds the documents. Blast published the letter and the minutes; no other outlet has said it saw them. The prime minister's office declined to comment, and AFP reported no government response as of Sunday.
- Whether anything was built. No operator has confirmed or denied preparing the block, and none was ordered.
- Operational detail rests on Blast's reading of the minutes — the 14:00 activation, the twelve-hour ceiling, the mobile-only scope.
- The numbers differ by source. The interior ministry counted 410,000 demonstrators, 110,000 in Paris; the CGT counted nearly 800,000. Sunday's provisional toll: 1,314 arrests, 53 officers injured, 24 shops looted.
No court has ruled on any of it. We will update this post if Matignon answers, if an operator confirms the request, or if a suspension is ordered before a future demonstration.
No comments yet